The High Court of Karnataka has held that the State government’s June 10, 2020 notification, issued amid the economic hardship caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, cannot be read as a perpetual prohibition on filling vacancies through grant-in-aid in private aided educational institutions. A Division Bench of Justice D.K. Singh and Justice H. Shanthi Bhushan observed that while Clause 2 of the notification expressly barred filling vacancies arising from retirement, death, resignation or other reasons during financial year 2020-21 due to pandemic-related financial constraints, Clause 3 — stating no fresh consent could be given for filling vacant posts — could not be construed as an indefinite recruitment ban.
The Bench also held that a February 2023 communication barring the filling of grant-in-aid vacancies that arose after December 31, 2015, should not by itself be treated as an independent government policy or statutory instrument imposing a blanket ban. It noted that the 2020 notification, read as a whole, was issued in the context of the pandemic’s financial difficulties and neither fixed December 31, 2015, as a cut-off nor expressly imposed a permanent prohibition on recruitment in aided institutions. The court said the 2023 restriction was issued without any lawful basis.
The Bench clarified that Section 52(2) of the Karnataka Education Act, 1983, empowers the State to sanction or refuse grant-in-aid for good and sufficient reasons but does not independently confer power to impose a general prohibition on filling vacancies in aided institutions. It added that its findings did not mean every vacancy arising after December 31, 2015, must be filled or that the State was bound to sanction grant-in-aid for each such vacancy; the government could frame an appropriate policy consistent with the Act and Rules, keeping its financial capacity in view.
The court said the competent authority, on receiving a request to fill grant-in-aid vacancies, must examine applications from individual aided institutions independently, considering sanctioned strength, the nature and date of vacancies, existing teaching and student strength, staffing pattern, reservation requirements and financial implications. It made clear that prior government permission remains mandatory and that aided institutions cannot recruit without it. The order came while partly allowing the State government’s appeal against a December 8, 2023, single-judge order on a petition by the Karnataka Rajya Anudanitha Shikshana Samsthegalu Okkuta, and set aside that order to the extent it treated prior permission as a mere intimation requirement and limited the authority’s scrutiny to reservation roster compliance.
