The Bihar State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission on Wednesday ordered a laparoscopic surgeon to pay ₹30 lakh in compensation for gross negligence after a surgical gauze was left inside a patient's abdomen during a gallbladder operation, leading to her death.

The case relates to Nibha Singh, 53, wife of Mani Kant Singh, a Madhepura resident. She consulted Dr. Rajesh Kumar Singh at Gayatri Nursing Home in Saharsa and underwent gallbladder surgery on March 19, 2016. Her health deteriorated rapidly afterwards, with severe abdominal pain, vomiting and bowel obstruction. The cause remained unidentified despite examinations at several hospitals until an emergency laparotomy at Sir Ganga Ram Hospital in New Delhi found a blood-soaked surgical gauze measuring 15x4x3 cm inside her abdomen, which had caused peritonitis. She died on July 1, 2016, hours after being discharged.

The bench of President Justice Sanjay Kumar and Judicial Member Md Shamim Akhtar held that leaving surgical materials inside a patient during an operation amounts to gross negligence, citing Supreme Court and National Commission rulings. The Commission observed that the doctor failed to act on her repeated visits with complaints of severe abdominal pain and distension, advised symptomatic medicines instead of timely imaging, and did not establish safety checklists for postoperative complications. It said the misdiagnosis was preventable and that the doctor failed to meet the reasonable standard of care expected of a medical professional.

The Commission directed the doctor to pay ₹30,00,000 as compensation to the aggrieved husband, along with ₹20,000 towards litigation costs, within 60 days of receiving the order. Failure to pay within the stipulated timeframe will attract interest at 8% per annum.