CPI(M) State Secretariat member P. Jayarajan has alleged that the Ariyil Shukkoor case was a politically motivated conspiracy by the then UDF government and IUML leadership, with Kerala Police assistance, to target the CPI(M). Speaking to reporters outside the SBI Special Court in Kochi on Thursday after Special Judge P. Sabarinathan acquitted him, former Kalliasseri MLA T.V. Rajesh and 16 others, Mr. Jayarajan claimed invoking IPC Section 118 was part of a conspiracy theory. He alleged that although he and Rajesh were lying injured in hospital, police charged them under Section 118 and arraigned two League sympathisers as witnesses, fabricating a claim that a conspiracy was hatched inside the hospital room. After taking over the investigation, the CBI added IPC Section 120 and developed a fresh conspiracy narrative with five witnesses, Mr. Jayarajan alleged, adding that the central agency reinforced rather than corrected the politically motivated course. He claimed a major reason for the acquittal was that certain individuals within the IUML were unwilling to stand by fabricated testimony, and said the League leadership and then UDF government leaders owe the people an apology.

Mr. Rajesh alleged the conspiracy theory and "party court" narrative were deliberately fabricated to undermine the CPI(M)'s influence among minority communities, with the propaganda campaign beginning just before the Neyyattinkara by-election, a UDF stronghold, and being carefully planned and executed by the UDF leadership. He said the two League sympathisers cited as witnesses had stated in sworn affidavits before the Taliparamba Magistrate Court that they had never visited CPI(M) leaders in the hospital room. He alleged false witnesses were created to place Mr. Jayarajan, himself and the party in the dock and to wage a misinformation campaign against the CPI(M), and demanded that the Muslim League leadership, the Congress leadership of that period and the then Home Minister publicly apologise.